The Copper Beeches...

Has One of the Most Intriguing Mysteries in Any Holmes Story!

"You look at these scattered houses, and you are impressed by their beauty. I look at them, and the only thought which comes to me is a feeling of their isolation and of the impunity with which crime may be committed there."

What's one thing about The Copper Beeches that you won't forget long after you've read the story?

I'd say it is the deep mystery it creates as you read it.

There comes a point in the story, when you just can't think of a possible ending.

You want to know why so many crazy occurrences are happening in the life of this one woman...

And - talking of this one woman, what if you wanted a second thing about The Copper Beeches you won't forget? I'd say that would be the client in the story.

She's one of the most intelligent, courageous and self-aware women I've seen in any Sherlock Holmes story. I mean, generally clients are like - "Holmes save me, I have no freakin' idea."

But this one's like, "I need your help Holmes and here's exactly the data you need."

As Sherlock Holmes says to her:

"You seem to have acted all through this matter like a very brave and sensible girl..."

That's How The Copper Beeches Is

Of course there are some nice Holmesian deductions in the story as well but for me: 'rocking mystery + cool client' pretty much sums The Copper Beeches up...

Here go my ratings of the story!

Introduction/Initial deduction

Not There!

Mystery and Weirdness in the Problem

10/10

The Showcasing of Holmes' Deductive Powers

8/10

The Drama in the Story or Twist in the End

7/10

Average Rating: 8.33/10


What's the Mystery/Problem Here?

Miss Violet Hunter has come to Sherlock Holmes with a simple request:

Could he help her decide whether to take up a certain job or not?

Now normally such a request would be beneath Holmes. I mean, he's used to solving more difficult problems than that!

But this job is a very interesting one.

Miss Hunter will be a governess - but she is being paid more than double the normal wages. She was selected without being asked anything about her teaching skills. She needs to cut her long hair off before she joins. AND - she needs to wear a blue dress and sit in different positions in the house...

Of course things look awry!

It is obvious that there's more to the job than just being a governess - something - shall we say sinister? Every point in the job description screams: why?

Here's what Holmes says when Miss Hunter asks for an opinion,

"I confess that it is not the situation which I should like to see a sister of mine apply for."

Miss Hunter however does join and the case deepens...What happens next is what the story is about!

Spoiler Alert: Skip to the trivia section if you haven't read the story yet!


Magical Moments From The Copper Beeches

1 The Moment When Miss Violet Finds the Hair in the Drawer

Miss Hunter's settled in her weird new job when what does she find in a locked drawer in her room?

Her own freaking hair - the hair that she had to cut off to be accepted for this job!

When I read this first, I really got freaked out. To make matters more intriguing - Miss Violet has her actual sample of hair in her bag. So whose hair is this in the drawer?

Mis Violet Hunter examining the two hair samples she finds with shock!

This image was first drawn by Czech illustrator Josef Friedrich (Thanks Ignisart!)

This scene was very thrilling for me - because of the vision it created. I'd say, it's perfectly suited for a movie.

Imagine the heroine pulling out a drawer and being startled by her own hair! Yup - this is one of the magic moments in the story.

2 The Moment When Miss Violet Hears Someone Walking Inside That Room

There's this secret wing in The Copper Beeches, the place where Miss Violet works.

This wing is always locked.

Now one way to think about such locked wings is, "That's none of my business." Another way to think about such wings is - "I need to find out why this is locked and why one of the windows of that wing is open."

Miss Violet Hunter - is adventurous - and one day - when the lock is not properly fastened, in she goes. The magical or rather heart numbing moment comes when - she hears footsteps from one of the rooms in the locked wing. That moment - so well created by Doyle - is definitely one of my magical moments in the story.

I mean the way he suddenly mentions... footsteps, can give you the jitters when you read the story for the first time. ;-)

3 The Moment When Holmes Clears the Whole Mystery in a Matter of Fact Way

When Holmes has all his data - he comes up with a superb solution to the whole mystery. He says it in such a matter of fact way - as they're all sitting in an inn - the governess, Watson and Holmes - that it is well...magical. :-)

Here's what he says:

"Of course there is only one feasible explanation. You have been brought there to impersonate someone, and the real person is imprisoned in this chamber. That is obvious.


As to who this prisoner is, I have no doubt that it is the daughter, Miss Alice Rucastle..."

This is definitely the moment that I love in all Holmes stories - the final revelation that makes it all look a tad too simple.

4 The Moment When the Dog Gets Rucastle

Doyle knows how to create drama - even when the mystery's been solved!

The climax scene in the story occurs when Rucastle, Miss Violet Hunter's employer catches Holmes and Watson in the secret room!

Off he goes to get his terrible wild dog...

The dog pounces on the villain in The Copper Beeches

That's the dog pouncing on the owner of the house - (drawn by Josef Friedrich in 1906)

Any first time reader will wonder, "This guy's gone to get his wild dog - how will Holmes escape?"

The climax occurs when the dog - which listens only to a certain servant in the house - pounces on its owner and gets him by the throat. 

That is the moment when your body really eases down and you relax.

"Ah, so that's the story.", you say. :-)


The Copper Beeches: Cool Trivia!

1 The Copper Beeches is the Only Story With a Surviving Movie Version Supervised by Doyle!

Now, if I told you: "The Copper Beeches has been made into a movie.", you might smile.

I mean - Sherlock Holmes movies are nothing new - there've been loads of them.

The cool thing however is that 8 Holmes stories were made into silent films  in 1912 by Adrien Caillard under the actual supervision of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

Unfortunately, almost all of these movies are now lost. The only one that exists is...The Copper Beeches.

That is special! Here it is:

2 What on Earth Are Copper Beeches?

I was pretty intrigued because I really had no idea.

Here's what I found out:

A copper beech is a special type of beech tree that has purple leaves that turn green in summer. It was considered to be a "rich man's tree" because of the difficulty in obtaining it.

That's it!

These trees are present just outside the door of Colonel Munro in the story.

Here's a picture of a copper beech tree.

Copper Beech Tree

Spoiler Alert: Move on to point 4 if you haven't yet read the story!

3 Where Are the Places Mentioned in The Copper Beeches?

Here's a picture that shows all the places in the story. Let's begin with London...

The places mentioned in The Copper Beeches

4 Money Matters: How Much Was 4 Pounds a Month Then?

Miss Violet Hunter - our dear client - used to earn 4 pounds a month at her previous job as a governess. She is offered 10 pounds a month in her new job.

The question is: what on earth would that money mean now?

Well this government website says that 4 pounds in 1890 would be the same as 240 pounds in 2005. That's around $387 a month. Hmm...

10 Pounds a month would mean around $970 a month today. That's the salary sher's offered in her new job.

How the value of money in Britain has changed!

That seems quite low, doesn't it? But maybe most wages were that way in those days - quite low.

But then - Miss Violet Hunter also had her apartment and food costs covered, I guess. That's something too...

5 Just Curious: Who Was a Governess in Those Times?

I've always been curious about the word governess - what Miss Violet Hunter is in The Copper Beeches. I mean - is she some sort of teacher? Do we have governesses these days?

Apparently, a governess was like a female private tutor for small kids. These days there are schools almost everywhere - but in those days there were hardly any schools in the countryside. So rich guys in the country would hire these governesses to teach their kids the basics - reading, writing, arithmetic, maybe a bit of French, some music, some drawing...

In those days it was like this: women had no other occupation they could pursue with social sanction. If you were a woman and did anything other than be a governess, or a private school manager - you were considered to be a part of the "lower class".

Sad, but true.

So being a governess meant you were a part of the upper class but you had money problems. 

I'm definitely very glad about the improvement in the way we treat women now - compared to those times.


So - well, that's about The Copper Beeches.  Are you saying you haven't read the story yet? OK, here's how to read it...




Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name (optional)
Then

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you The Sherlock Holmes Fan Gazette.
Email Address
First Name

(No spam ever. Your e-mail is safe.)
Learn more about this monthly newsletter.

New! Comments

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.