Sherlock: A Study in Pink is...

...A 'First Episode' Like No Other!

John: "Why didn't I think of that?"


Sherlock: "Because you're an idiot. No, no, no don't look like that. Practically everyone is."

A Study in Pink is the kind of TV episode you can watch many times - because each time you watch it, you'll discover something new!

At least I did.

For instance, when watching it for the first time, I paid attention to Sherlock's outstanding deductions.

Then, at another time, the music made me say, "This is superb!"

Yet another time, it was the humour that cracked me up more than the other times (I've watched A Study in Pink 4 times so far).

Fans watching A Study in Pink

Well, you get it: there's a lot that's been done right in A Study in Pink.

Let me flag this post off with my ratings for the episode...

Sherlock's Uber-Cool Deductions

10/10

Fun Scenes

8/10

Dialogues to Remember

9/10

Thrill/Adventure/Drama

9/10

Average Rating: 9/10


So, What's the Mystery/Puzzle Here?

A Study in Pink plot

Sherlock's client in this episode is Detective Inspector Lestrade.

Lestrade's problem? Three suicides which are incredibly similar!

Now, that's not possible, is it?

Why would three people who don't know each other take exactly the same kind of pills and die one after the other in three different parts of London?

And yet, investigations show that these guys took the pills themselves. So, it has to be suicide, right?

But again, all three victims seemed pretty happy. They had no reason to die. And there was no suicide note. And no other evidence.

To top it, all of them were all found in weird places they had no business to be in - dead.

So it can't be suicide. The case is a bit bamboozling, to put it clearly.

When A Study in Pink begins, a fourth victim has died in exactly the same way!

There's only one difference: this woman has left evidence. She has scratched 'RACHE' on the floor.

It's now up to Sherlock to deduce the daylights out of the crime scene, mix those deductions with that 'RACHE' clue and find out what or who killed all these people and why!

It's fun to watch the case become more intriguing as Sherlock follows one clue after the other.

As Sherlock himself puts it to his affable landlady, Mrs. Hudson:

The game, Mrs. Hudson, is on!


Top 5 Magical Moments From A Study in Pink

1 The 'John Meets Sherlock' Moment

Just like the original novel A Study in Scarlet, Sherlock Holmes first meets John Watson in A Study in Pink.

That moment has to be awesome - and it is.

They've shown it really well in A Study in Pink.

In fact, here's the scene itself:

The way Sherlock deduces all these things from John's phone is cool!

By the way, this is Sherlock's first 'deduction session' in the entire series.

I also love the way this scene ends as Sherlock says 'bye' to John as he leaves. He says:

The name is Sherlock Holmes and the address is 221B, Baker Street!

That last line is not some earth-shattering revelation or anything but the way Benedict Cumberbatch says it is magical.

2 The Moment When Sherlock and John Barge Out of 221B, Baker Street!

It's always fun to watch Sherlock Homes and John Watson embark on a case - and I loved watching that moment in A Study in Pink.

There's nothing much 'happening' in this moment but it filled me with anticipation and excitement as I watched.

Here's a screenshot of that moment as Sherlock and John barge out of 221B, Baker Street. 

The game, Mrs. Hudson, is on

Fabulous music - check.

Fantastic visuals - check.

The thrill of the case about to begin - check.

In my 'magical moments' list - check!

Spoiler Alert: If you've not watched Sherlock's A Study in Pink yet, skip the next few points and move on to the Trivia Section!

3 The Moment When Sherlock Deduces Stuff About the Woman in Pink

Now this is something that is completely unique about BBC Sherlock. Many of Sherlock's observations appear on the screen as text while he is thinking.

So in this sense BBC's Sherlock is one step ahead of the books - ahead because you get to know exactly what Sherlock is observing in real time!

Take a look at these fascinating screenshots from A Study in Pink as Sherlock observes the fourth murder/suicide's scene...

On-screen text in A Study in Pink

And here is just ONE of the awesome deductions Sherlock makes as he observes all these things:

Sherlock's deduction in A Study in Pink

This moment has to be one of the top 5 magical moments in A Study in Pink.

4 The Unforgettable Chase

In A Study in Pink, Sherlock plans out a way to trap the murderer at 22, Northumberland Street.

And so, Sherlock and John wait for the murderer to come...

This 'waiting for the culprit in hiding' moment comes many times in the original Sherlock Holmes stories and novels too.

In fact, it is one of the most exciting moments in the stories...

...The moment is just as exciting in BBC Sherlock's A Study in Pink as well!

So well, as Sherlock and John wait in Northumberland Street, a taxi arrives near them and stops.

In a flash Sherlock is after it! 

Sherlock and John both chase the cab on foot.

As usual, with eye-popping presence of mind, Sherlock calculates the cab's route in his head and rushes after it using special shortcuts.

These guys have shown the chase so well, I'll bet your adrenaline will start flowing as you witness Sherlock and John run - especially with the matching background score.

When finally, Sherlock does catch up with the taxi, he finds the chase was...well, a waste.

So he tries to get himself out of this muddle by waving a police ID and saying to the guy in the cab:

'Detective Inspector Lestrade'

And then he tells John:

"Yeah, I pickpocket him (Lestrade) when he's annoying. You can keep that one (the ID). I got plenty at the flat."

Oh, this is fun. :-)

5 The Moment When Greg Lestrade and Sherlock Holmes Pull Up Their Sleeves

You've got to give Mark Gatiss, Steven Moffat and the others credit: they've added cartloads of fun in each episode.

In A Study in Pink, Detective Inspector Greg Lestrade orders a drugs bust to raid Sherlock's apartment.

Sherlock's obviously annoyed.

He's like:

"I don't even smoke." 

He folds back his shirt sleeve and shows Inspector Greg his nicotine patch - the patch he wears to quit smoking.

Greg says: 

"Neither do I." 

Greg then folds back his shirt sleeve and shows his patch.

Whenever I see this scene, I smile.

It is ridiculous to see both of them boasting to each other about their nicotine patches with a serious case out there to be solved. :-)

Take a look at this funny picture:

Funny Sherlock and Greg Lestrade scene from A Study in Pink

Right after this scene, by the way, comes another funny dialogue when Sherlock gets irritated because he can't think.

He's like, "Everyone get the heck outta here! I want to think."

Here's what he says:

"Shut up, everybody! Don't move, don't speak, don't breathe.


Anderson, face the other way. You're putting me off."

That moment's fun too!


A Study in Pink: Cool Trivia!

1 A Study in Pink's Vital Stats and Who's Who

Here's an interesting picture that tells you some fascinating stuff about A Study in Pink:

A Study in Pink - Vital Stats and Who's Who

2 Where Are the 'Real' Places Where A Study in Pink Was Shot?

There's 221B, Baker Street where John and Sherlock start living.

There's St. Barts Hospital where Sherlock conducts not so pleasing (horrifying?) experiments...

There's 22, Northumberland Street where Sherlock and John start a certain hair-raising chase.

So, where are all these places in reality? Did the episode's shooting take place at exactly the places they 'show' on the screen?

Here's an interesting image that tells you the important real places from A Study in Pink - places - where A Study in Pink was really shot!

Places Mentioned in A Study in Pink

3 There Are Many, Many 'Hidden Hints' About the Original Sherlock Holmes Stories in A Study in Pink!

Can you guess how many of the original Sherlock Holmes stories and novels are somehow hinted at in A Study in Pink?

The story of A Study in Pink itself is, of course, based loosely on A Study in Scarlet. But there's so much more.

In fact, I've found allusions/references to at least 15 Sherlock Holmes stories and novels in A Study in Pink!

So, for instance there's a chapter called 'The Science of Deduction' in The Sign of the Four and Sherlock's blog in A Study in Pink is 'The Science of Deduction.'

Sherlock Holmes sends a telegram that says, "Come at once if convenient....." in the original story The Creeping Man while he sends a text message with the same words in A Study in Pink.

Sherlock Holmes says, "The game is afoot!" in The Adventure of the Abbey Grange and he says, "The game, Mrs. Hudson is on!" in A Study in Pink...

...And mind you, I've just scratched the 'tip' of the iceberg here.

Take a look at this fun graphic that shows you all the stories that are referred to in A Study in Pink (at least the ones I could find!):

Original Sherlock Holmes stories referred to in a A Study in Pink

4 What Are Those Places Shown Before the Initial Credits of A Study in Pink?

Whenever A Study in Pink, or for that matter, any BBC Sherlock episode begins, there are these cool visuals with a Ferris wheel rotating.

I've always wondered: what exactly is that place shown?

This is what I'm talking about:

The London Eye and Big Ben in Sherlock credits

If you're wondering too, well, then here's the deal about the Ferris wheel: it is a real Ferris wheel in London.

It was opened to the general public in the year 2000 and it's one of the largest such wheels in the world. It's name is 'The London Eye.' The whole thing is 135 metres high and you can get this amazing view of London when you're at the top of the wheel.

An interesting fact here is that The London Eye is sponsored by big companies every few years. Right now, the sponsor is Coca-Cola. This means you should call it the Coca-Cola London Eye!

The other monument shown is the Big Ben - London's famous clock-tower.

The Big Ben is situated in London's famous 'Westminster' area - the area that has the Parliament. It was built in 1858 and it's official name now is Elizabeth Tower.

And the third place that you can see in the lower picture?

That's 'Piccadily Circus.' It's not that kind of 'circus',- it's actually a street junction. It's famous for it's glamorous neon and video ads.

It's like this famous junction that's always well lit and that gives you loads of shopping and entertainment options nearby.

5 What Are Those Phones in A Study in Pink?

Phones are pretty important in A Study in Pink.

The 'woman in pink' - the woman whose murder Sherlock's investigating has a pink phone. 

Sherlock himself has a phone he keeps using to text all sorts of crazy things to John and Lestrade.

And then there's John's phone - that says a metaphorical 'hello' to all of us when Sherlock deduces the deuce out of it. :-)

All these phones made me a bit curious: what's the make of each of these phones?

The guys at Sherlockology have found that out. These are the cell phones used in A Study in Pink according to them:

Phones in A Study in Pink

Thanks to Allstair Paterson for the iPhone picture.

Interesting, I'll say. 

Spoiler Alert: I tried to keep the spoilers out but they've crept right in, in points 6 and 7! So, if you haven't watched A Study in Pink yet, watch it now.

6 What's An Aneurysm?

In A Study in Pink, the villain - the cab driver - is dying of a brain aneurysm.

In A Study in Scarlet (the original novel), the killer is dying of an 'aortic' aneurysm ('aorta' is the main artery in the human body).

I had no idea what an aneurysm was - so I decided to find out.

Apparently, 'aneurysm' means that a part of a blood vessel has swelled up - like a mini-balloon. This generally happens because that portion of the blood vessel is weak.

There's not much of a problem when the swelling is there but when the swollen portion bursts - that's dangerous.

It can cause death.

Researchers have said that an aneurysm has way too many causes: diabetes, obesity, stress, drinking too much alcohol, old age, and genes...

...They can all cause this blood-vessel-swelling.

Treatment is possible but it is expensive and it's definitely not an easy thing.

One famous person who died of an aortic aneurysm was: Albert Einstein.

Apparently, he could be treated but Einstein was like - this is it. He said:

"It is tasteless to prolong life artificially."

I didn't know that.

7 What Exactly is the Difference Between Sociopath and Psychopath?

So there's this dialogue in a Study in Pink where the forensic expert Anderson and Sherlock Holmes are talking (taunting?).

When Anderson calls Sherlock a psychopath, Sherlock says:

"I’m not a psychopath, Anderson. I’m a high-functioning sociopath. Do your research."

That's a bit confusing. I mean - what exactly is the difference between a psychopath and a sociopath?

I thought I'd find out!

First, let's take a look at what the Oxford English Dictionary says:

Sociopath: A person with a personality disorder manifesting itself in extreme antisocial attitudes and behaviour.


Psychopath: A person suffering from chronic mental disorder with abnormal or violent social behaviour.

...And here's what the Merriam-Webster Dictionary says:

Sociopath: Someone who behaves in a dangerous or violent way towards other people and does not feel guilty about such behavior.


Psychopath: A person who is mentally ill, who does not care about other people, and who is usually dangerous or violent.

Well, as you can see, there isn't really much difference. Both people are asocial and they're both clueless when you mention the word 'compassion.'

Compassion is not understood by sociopaths as well as psychopaths

The only thing is that psychopaths are a bit more ill and violent than sociopaths.

It's like saying psychopaths are more intense versions of sociopaths.

Robert Hare - Psychopath Researcher

The famous 'psychopath researcher' Robert Hare says that the term sociopath can be used for people who're aloof and cold and manipulative because of social and environmental reasons

They had the wrong parents or the wrong friends or the wrong something because of which they're this way.

Psychopaths, on the other hand, are like that because of biological or genetic factors also

It's like saying psychopaths just have it all messed up in their heads. There's a 'chemical problem.' Sociopaths have gone wrong - and they can come back.

But then, psychologist Maria Konnikova doesn't think so.

She says all the differences are hogwash - psychopaths and sociopaths are just different words and they mean the same thing!

In fact, she says the word sociopath is passé, it isn't even used anymore....

...Well, you get the point. Both the words are pretty similar.

What Sherlock really wants to say, I guess, is something like this:

"Dude, I'm not mentally ill. I just hate all the mushy stuff with other humans because I find it to be silly. And I rock."

(Thanks to Vaninst.ca for the 'Robert Hare' picture.)


Have you watched A Study in Pink? I'd LOVE to hear your thoughts below!

...And if you haven't watched A Study in Pink yet, you're missing a fantastic work of art. 

Here's a link to buy the entire BBC Sherlock DVD set:



You can also watch A Study in Pink on Amazon Instant Video.
› A Study in Pink

Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name (optional)
Then

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you The Sherlock Holmes Fan Gazette.
Email Address
First Name

(No spam ever. Your e-mail is safe.)
Learn more about this monthly newsletter.

New! Comments

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.